Theatre Bay Area Chatterbox

Thursday, October 15, 2009

More Questions for Critics

As promised in the previous post about the Critics Panel that was held on Tuesday evening, I’ve sent the remaining audience questions to the critics and compiled their replies here.


"Sam [Hurwitt] made a comment about newspapers being able to reach those who are receptive but not inclined to seek out arts coverage. In the future of new media, how do the panelists think arts journalism--or marketing of theatre companies--can reach those who are receptive but not inclined to seek out arts coverage?"


Robert Hurwitt: Good question. Wish I knew or even had a clue. It's why people like me have trouble envisioning a world without newspapers -- and why I continue to read them and never even think to look at any online coverage unless someone points me to it.

Chloe Veltman: Aggregators like the iTunes podcast store are a great place to browse an extremely diverse range of commentary on everything from dog racing to David Mamet.

Jean Schiffman: Regarding reaching potential audiences through arts journalism, I think it's what we talked about--new media. Facebook, Twitter, etc. Regarding marketing theatre companies in general, let's not forget the best means ever: word of mouth. I go to my local Peet's almost every morning and have gotten to know a fairly large group of other regulars there. Some read the reviews in the Chronicle, some don't, none read reviews elsewhere--but all of them ask me what I've seen lately and what I recommend. And I hold forth. I've taken three of them (separately) to see shows, and many of them now go to theatre based on my recommendations. I wonder if audience members could be given incentives, or greater incentives than they are already getting, for talking up shows they like to their friends and acquaintances?


"Do you have metrics for what part of the paper people are reading?" "If you have a blog, what is your readership in terms of demographics and/or numbers?"


Robert Hurwitt: I don't know how the Chronicle tracks such things except for the obvious, number of hits (and appended comments) on the Gate. The main feedback I've heard for the past 10 years about demographics comes from focus groups.

Chloe Veltman: My blog gets about 1,000 hits a day.


"Are your publications planning to develop their web presence and arts coverage?"


Robert Hurwitt: Yes. The Chronicle has been way out ahead, I'm told, in establishing an online presence with the Gate and it's my impression that a lot of planning and work is going into developing its future. I have no idea what the thinking is in terms of changes to our online arts coverage at this point.

Chloe Veltman: SF Weekly is not planning on developing its arts coverage; not sure about web presence. I'd like to develop my coverage on Arts Journal further but I need to find a sustainable business model first. The other publications I freelance for don't show too many signs of expanding arts coverage.

Jean Schiffman: Web presence yes, arts coverage no.


"What can theatres do to keep arts coverage available?" "What can theatre companies do to help you? If not a letter-writing/email campaign, what might work?"


Robert Hurwitt: All I can say is that the more the editors are made aware that the readers want more arts coverage, the more likely they are to put resources there -- the emphasis is on readers, and potential readers. And, as you may have noticed, almost all papers want and print as many Letters to the Editor as they can get.

Jean Schiffman: I can't think of anything other than encouraging your audiences to write letters to the press in response to reviews (or lack thereof) and getting your press releases to us in a very timely manner, and with all the information therein. Many of my press releases arrive too late, and without all the necessary details.

Chloe Veltman: Encourage foundations about providing philanthropic support to people who write about the arts, e.g., bloggers. For example, artists who serve on the TBA CA$H grant committee might consider providing bloggers and podcasters with support.


"Arts journalism isn't the main focus of news journalism. So what is journalism currently doing in this area? Example: earlier this year I saw a fellowship in this sector."


Chloe Veltman: Some small efforts are being made to at least begin discussions about the field, mainly driven by philanthropy, e.g., National Arts Journalism Summit held on October 2 in LA; Andy Warhol foundation paying $30,000 to each of a number of bloggers in the visual arts (so far no one to my knowledge has stepped up to the plate for theatre journalists or other disciplines). More broadly, journalists are starting their own websites, etc. But oftentimes this is motivated by the fact that they've lost their jobs on newspapers rather than from deep-seated desire to be entrepreneurial.


"What can artists and arts administrators do to encourage the perpetuation of professional criticism?" "Writer credibility: bloggers and artists who also review and comment?"


Robert Hurwitt: Keep us honest. I think it's important to make the distinction: While editors may get their backs up when they think a theater is trying to engineer campaigns to get more coverage for its work, no one in the news business should ever take offense when theaters, directors, actors, designers, playwrights or anybody else writes or emails or phones to point out an error in our coverage. This point probably needs to be made in the Bay Area because there was a powerful editor in the '90s who became so protective of one of her critics that she threatened several companies with reduced coverage when they had the temerity to ask for corrections of errors in his copy. She is no longer in the business, that kind of practice is a violation of good journalism ethics and that is not the practice at any paper I know of.


"How do you decide what to cover?"


Robert Hurwitt: There are no hard-and-fast rules, but in general it boils down to my sense of a show's news value with some input from my editors. On rare occasions, an editor will suggest that I cover something I hadn't been considering a priority; more often, an editor will tell me there won't be room for as many reviews as I have scheduled or ask me to write an article that means I have to sacrifice one or more reviews in order not to work overtime (the paper rarely wants to pay overtime for arts coverage). News value partly depends on the size of the venue, which is one reason why every ACT and Berkeley Rep show and most Best of Broadway offerings will be covered, except when it's a show that's been here often before making yet another return. I prioritize certain theaters based on my sense of their track records and/or local or national profiles. So I try to cover every show at TheatreWorks, Cal Shakes, San Jose Rep, Marin Theatre Co, the Magic, Aurora and those companies, and as many as I can at SF Playhouse, Intersection, Shotgun, Lorraine Hansberry and a number of other companies. When it comes to the many other companies I have to choose between for the few remaining slots in my calendar, I tend to give priority to new work -- partly because 1) I believe that's more newsworthy than another staging of a show that's been seen here before (especially if it's received several stagings and/or is often done); 2) I think the creation of new work is one of the distinguishing features of Bay Area theater; 3) I've probably said all that I have to say about "Cats," "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest," "Cabaret," "Stones in His Pockets" or many others; and 4) I believe that any of those shows, and many others, are well-known enough already that they don't need the help of a review to attract attention.

Chloe Veltman: For SF Weekly: With rare exceptions the decision is partly governed by editorial restrictions, i.e., shows that have a run of at least a month and happen in San Francisco (rather than other parts of the Bay). Beyond that, I cover whatever to me looks interesting. Could be an actor/director/designer who's career intrigues me, a production of particular topical significance, an unusual reconstruction of a classic -- in other words, some esthetic ideas that make the play look like it stands out from the pack.

Jean Schiffman: I go through all my press releases well in advance and choose all the shows I want to see. Then I submit that list to my editor and she usually agrees to have me review half or less. I don't know how she makes her decisions. But I go to all of them anyway. I generally choose what I want to see by a variety of guidelines. Certain theatres, both large, mid-sized and tiny, I like very much and want to see everything they do pretty much no matter what. Beyond that, if actors I really like are in a particular show, I'll want to see it. Ditto for directors. I prefer to go to new plays rather than plays I've seen many times--although of course with really great plays I'll go to see many versions of them, especially if they're being done by a theatre whose work I like. Among the new plays, I look for plays by playwrights I like, or emerging playwrights that I've heard about. If I've seen a particular play within the past year or so, I'm unlikely to want to see another version of it.


That’s all for now, but there’s certainly a lot here to discuss, and if the conversation really takes off, I’ll be writing new posts on it.

Labels:

42 Comments:

At October 19, 2009 at 9:54 AM , Blogger Carl Benson said...

I think Robert Hurwitt's answer on how he decides what to cover is a bit odd. Right up front, he says the No. 1 determining factor is venue size:

"News value partly depends on the size of the venue, which is one reason why every ACT and Berkeley Rep show and most Best of Broadway offerings will be covered"

Now, these three venues, especially SHN's Best of Broadway, tend to produce internationally recognized work. Using ACT as an example, currently it is staging a Noel Coward show, followed by David Mamet's recent Broadway success "November," followed by Martin McDounough's "The Cripple of Inishman" and wrapping up the year with "A Christmas Carol."

But in the same paragraph that Mr. Hurwitt cites venue size as a key determining factor, he goes on to say this about why he does not cover famously recognizable shows:

"I believe that any of those shows, and many others, are well-known enough already that they don't need the help of a review to attract attention."

So I guess my question is, if these big, famous, touring shows are already so well known that they really don't need the paper's attention (SHN's "South Pacific" has the line "Winner of seven 2008 Tony Awards" on its poster), why does everything that gets staged at these venues immediately get covered?

While I don't understand that aspect of Mr. Hurwitt's response, I do appreciate his preference for covering new work, and think that new work is vital to any art scene anywhere. But again, I think his answer is a bit of a double edged sword in that because new work is generally staged at smaller venues, it stands less a chance of being reviewed.

Just some thoughts, but I really do appreciate each critic's honest response to these tough questions, and taking the time to answer them thoughtfully. Also, thanks to TBA for putting this together and to the critics for participating.

 
At August 29, 2017 at 8:20 AM , Blogger AVI Homeopathy said...

People who share their knowledge are the best kind of people. Thanks for sharing your ideas in this precious blog. homeopathy doctors in pratap nagar

 
At August 10, 2018 at 11:50 PM , Blogger Alex daina said...

Endless supply of the estimation of the auto and concession to the cash to be obtained, the borrower gets the chance to keep his or her auto. Borrowers can immediately get the cash they acquired when they have been affirmed. auto title loans chicago

 
At August 11, 2018 at 9:32 AM , Blogger geekpeaktech said...

Recover deleted messages from android

 
At November 6, 2018 at 7:01 AM , Blogger Akshay Thakur said...

Calendar 2019: Calendar 2019 Printable
January 2019 Calendar : January Calendar 2019
February 2019 Calendar : February 2019 Calendar
March Calendar 2019 March 2019 Calendar
Gujarathi Calendar : Gujarati Calendar 2019
Telugu Calendar 2019 : Telugu Calendar 2019
Hindu Calendar : Hindu Calendar 2019
Find Marathi Kalnirnay 2019 : Kalnirnay 2019 Calendar

 
At January 14, 2019 at 9:27 PM , Blogger Mary robinson said...

Thank you for other magnificent post. The place else could anybody get that kind of information in such an ideal manner of writing Thesis editing services

 
At January 25, 2019 at 2:19 AM , Blogger Cipro said...

Thanks for your informative blog! Your article helped me to understand the future of programming language.
You like games, play bike simulator 3d supermoto 2
Keep on updating your with such awesome information. Thanks!

 
At March 5, 2019 at 3:12 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, know About Fazlur-Rahman Khan biography? Visit Our page or Fazlur Rahman Khan Bio, Born, Age, Death, Facts, Family, Secrets

 
At March 5, 2019 at 3:13 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, know About Matthew Gray Gubler biography? Visit Our page or Matthew Gray Gubler Secrets, Bio, Trivia & Updates | Celebrity Ping

 
At March 11, 2019 at 1:52 AM , Blogger Mabel Robert said...

I have bookmarked your blog; your ideas on this topic were very helpful. Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic Custom essay writing service .

 
At October 15, 2019 at 6:13 AM , Blogger shareit said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At October 29, 2019 at 6:15 AM , Blogger Jennifer said...

It’s impressive that you are getting thoughts from this article as well as from our argument made at this time.Here is my webpage
shareit for pc
xender for pc
shareit pc
xender apk
shareit apk
xender web
shareit for laptop
xender for windows
shareit downloading
xender download
xender for ios
shareit for ios

 
At November 1, 2019 at 11:24 PM , Blogger Unknown said...

The average annual salary for a movie critic was $82,000 as of 2013, according to the job website Indeed. Since these professionals are writers who must deliver interesting reviews that sell publications, bachelor's degrees in journalism, English or communications are usually required.

>>> http://www.trumbullvolleyballclub.com/2019/10/10/install-garageband-for-pc/

 
At November 28, 2019 at 1:09 AM , Blogger cobb steven said...

windows spotlight quiz is an application used in windows 10. it changes the background images in users login windows. these are hd images and never repeated.

 
At March 3, 2020 at 2:04 AM , Blogger jenifer90 said...

It is a great article. You will surely like this also because it is a great stuff
Coronavirus Tracker For PC

 
At March 6, 2020 at 10:38 PM , Blogger andrew lincon said...

The web-based interface of linksys router ip address acts as a control panel that lets you make changes in the network settings.

 
At April 12, 2020 at 2:02 PM , Blogger Best IPTV Services said...

IPTV Service Provider the cheapest and highest quality IPTV Subscriptions and also Cheap IPTV Reseller plans, more than 50000 Live TV Channels & VOD.

 
At June 16, 2020 at 4:56 AM , Blogger Rayan Bernard said...

That's a really good interview. I also know a platform where you can learn more about relevant parental control tools and related services - check https://www.mspy.com, they even have a simple app for a convenient phone tracking.

 
At October 25, 2020 at 4:15 AM , Blogger Darren Demers said...

I go through all my press releases well in advance and choose all the shows I want to see. Then I submit that list to my editor and she usually agrees to have me review half or less. I don't know how she makes her decisions. But I go to all of them anyway. I generally choose what I want to see by a variety of guidelines. Certain theatres, both large, mid-sized and tiny, I like very much and want to see everything they do pretty much no matter what. Beyond that, if actors I really like are in a particular show, I'll want to see it. Ditto for directors. bed sheets online shopping lowest price , summer comforter sets , gul ahmed bed sheets online shopping , bridal bed sheet with price , king size duvet cover , vicky razai website , sofa covers near me I prefer to go to new plays rather than plays I've seen many times--although of course with really great plays I'll go to see many versions of them, especially if they're being done by a theatre whose work I like. Among the new plays, I look for plays by playwrights I like, or emerging playwrights that I've heard about. If I've seen a particular play within the past year or so, I'm unlikely to want to see another version of it.

 
At November 2, 2020 at 12:50 AM , Blogger sharai libas said...

Good to see you here, good information for us, online abaya shopping in pakistan with free shipping and cash on delivery Click Here

 
At November 21, 2020 at 10:51 AM , Blogger How they do said...

plays rather than plays I've seen many times--although of course with really great plays I'll go to see many versions of them, especially if they're being done by a theatre whose work I like. Among the new plays, I look for plays by playwrights I like, or emerging playwrights that I've heard about. If I've seen a particular play within the past year or so, I'm unlikely to want to see another version of it.
Health center 21
Uncovered lightbulbs may expose food to which type of hazard
Who invented peanut butter
Canadian Marcellus Edson patented which food item in 1884?
Food recovery network

 
At December 23, 2020 at 12:57 AM , Blogger sharai libas said...

"I Really Loved this post. This is very infomative Post. Keep updated More. Do you want to Buy Ahram? Best offers in Ahram Pakistan
with free shipping and cash on delivery"

 
At March 24, 2021 at 2:32 AM , Blogger ekoelmer said...

You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website.

Website
Information

 
At June 21, 2021 at 1:05 AM , Blogger Emcee Singapore said...

Looking for an experienced professional emcee in Singapore who is known in the world of weddings and events? Introducing Emcee James Yang, one of Singapore's most sought-after Emcees & a veteran in the corporate world and wedding industry.

Singapore Emcee James Yang is a dynamic emcee whose magnetic personality engages the unlike any other master of ceremonies. Events hosted by him are like a dialogue between himself the audience. He speaks, they laugh, he charms, they respond in kind; every moment is compelling and interactive.

His reputation as a Professional Singapore Emcee has gradually risen over the years and his career is proof of his versatility- from celebrities to military personnel and numerous event/wedding companies, he's collaborated with them all. Whichever the occasion, James is often the Top Choice Emcee amongst clients.

 
At November 12, 2021 at 9:40 PM , Blogger LeolaRistau said...

If you are suffering from a lack of energy, low sex drive, inability to get or maintain an erection or other complications related to prostate issues or diabetes causing erectile dysfunction, we can help provide treatment for ED and other underlying issues.erectile dysfunction medical care from a trained physician

 
At March 21, 2022 at 6:57 PM , Blogger igoal88 said...

It really is good to know that this topic is being covered also on this web site.
เว็บ igoal

 
At April 12, 2022 at 10:43 PM , Blogger aum12 said...

It is a great article. You will surely like this also because it is a great stuff. Panera Breakfast Menu

 
At June 15, 2022 at 7:18 AM , Blogger Furniture Rumah Terbaru said...

Mebel Jepara
Mebel Jepara
Mebel Jepara

 
At June 23, 2022 at 1:17 AM , Blogger cherry456 said...

Goa Board SSC Syllabus 2023 – goaresults.nic.in Goa Board 10th Exam 2023 SSC Book 2023 Hindi & English Medium PDF, Goa Board SSC Syllabus 2023 – The Syllabus 2023 of Goa Board SSC class 10th Examination 2023 is likely to be Goa 10th Syllabus 2023 announced in the last week of May, 2023. Goa Board SSC Syllabus 2023 The Goa Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education GBSHSE, Alto Betin Goa conducts SSc Exam for every academic year. This year Goa Boad will also conduct the SSC Goa board SSc Previous Syllabus we can expect that, the Syllabus 2023 of Goa board for SSC Exam 2023 may be published in the month of MAY, 2023 lass week.

 
At January 29, 2023 at 1:30 AM , Blogger anna said...

Yokheh is a souvenir of Shiraz and is very similar to Kermanshah's kak. To cook this delicious sweet, several layers of dough are prepared with wheat flour, local butter, eggs, etc. Among these pastes there are types of pistachio powder, cinnamon, sugar powder and almond slices. It is good to know that the difference between Yokheh Shiraz and Kak is in its dough. In fact, Yokheh dough is made from a thinner dough than Kermanshah cake. ( https://rb.gy/ngyh8d )

 
At September 6, 2023 at 11:03 PM , Blogger allan bennett said...

The author cannot provide specific reviews for "theatrebayarea" or other organizations or websites due to limited access to real-time internet data. To find reviews, they recommend visiting their official website, online review platforms, or searching for articles related to their productions or services. Additionally, they suggest utilizing social media and theater-related forums to gather feedback from theatergoers and members of the community, providing valuable insights into Theatre Bay Area's activities.abogado Baltimore flsa

 
At September 20, 2023 at 4:54 AM , Blogger Linda Glori said...

"More Questions for Critics" is a thought-provoking article that encourages critical thinking and analysis. It presents insightful questions, prompting readers to consider different perspectives. Real-world examples and case studies provide practical context. The article also offers suggestions for further reading or resources on critical thinking, urging readers to engage with criticism in a nuanced way.New York No-Fault State Divorce

 
At October 21, 2023 at 4:48 AM , Blogger paul said...

"MORE QUESTIONS FOR CRITICS" challenges traditional critic roles in literature, film, and art, encouraging deeper thinking and a reconsideration of creator-critic relationships. It calls for a nuanced, open-minded approach to critique, emphasizing constructive dialogue and a more nuanced understanding of criticism.Divorcio Rápido y Fácil en Nueva York

 
At November 10, 2023 at 9:51 PM , Blogger Leo said...

"More Questions for Critics" is a thought-provoking and engaging book that encourages critical thinking and analysis. The author poses insightful questions, challenging readers to deepen their understanding and approach various subjects with a critical lens. The diverse range of topics makes it a valuable resource for intellectual stimulation, catalyzing introspection and meaningful discussions, ultimately encouraging readers to embrace a more analytical mindset.Conducción Descuidada en Nueva Jersey

 
At January 8, 2024 at 3:02 AM , Blogger liam said...

"More Questions for Critics" is a thought-provoking and engaging article that encourages a deeper exploration of critical thinking. The author poses insightful questions that prompt readers to reflect on their perspectives and consider alternative viewpoints. The article's clarity and structure make it accessible for a broad audience, fostering a sense of intellectual curiosity. By challenging traditional modes of thinking, it sparks meaningful conversations and intellectual growth. In summary, a well-crafted piece that invites readers to embrace a more nuanced and open-minded approach to criticism. New York Divorce Maintenance Calculator

 
At February 28, 2024 at 12:31 AM , Blogger Paul Walker said...

"MORE QUESTIONS FOR CRITICS" is a resource that encourages critical thinking and understanding of subject matter through thought-provoking questions. It encourages constructive dialogue and expands perspectives by posing challenging questions. It encourages critics to explore new angles and consider alternative viewpoints, making it a valuable tool for elevating discourse and promoting intellectual growth.
abogado del capítulo 7 cerca de mí

 
At March 15, 2024 at 8:27 AM , Blogger harold07finch07 said...


Insightful responses from the critics, shedding light on the challenges and opportunities in arts journalism today.
divorce new york no fault

 
At March 23, 2024 at 3:35 AM , Blogger Bennyjo said...

Informative and engaging! Theatre Bay Area Chatterbox provides valuable insights into the world of theater. A must-read for theater enthusiasts and professionals alike best personal injury attorney in virginia

 
At April 3, 2024 at 2:37 AM , Blogger Tomxavior said...

"MORE QUESTIONS FOR CRITICS" is an article that encourages critics to delve deeper into their analysis and evaluations. It challenges conventional perspectives and encourages a nuanced approach to criticism. The article encourages constructive feedback and continuous improvement in various fields, sparking meaningful discussions and promoting critical thinking among readers. It serves as a valuable resource for critics aiming to enhance the quality and depth of their assessments.
Domestic Violence Lawyer New Jersey

 
At April 13, 2024 at 7:33 AM , Blogger shaunmurphy said...

Such insightful responses from the panelists! It's encouraging to see discussions on the future of arts journalism and the efforts being made to adapt to new media landscapes.
Is there No Fault Divorce in New York

 
At May 4, 2024 at 9:08 AM , Blogger harold07finch07 said...

What a insightful compilation of responses from the critics!
New York Divorce Laws Adultery

 
At July 30, 2024 at 2:42 AM , Blogger Alex said...

They can negotiate fair agreements between spouses or advocate for your rights in court. Given the emotional and legal challenges of divorce, having a lawyer can provide essential support. If you're dealing with Middlesex County Driving Without a License Attorney , a divorce lawyer can offer expert legal guidance. Contact us now for more information.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home