Talking About Declining Arts Education, Armed with New Numbers
Recapping Research: the SPPA Follow-Up Monographs, Part 1
Yesterday, I had the opportunity to listen in on a two-hour presentation hosted by Sunil Iyengar, the head of research at the NEA. The topic was three monographs the NEA commissioned to delve into the data gathered from the Survey on Public Participation in the Arts (SPPA). This benchmark report, which is fielded every four years, looks at the arts attendance habits of just under 20,000 people across the country in order to understand who’s going to what, who’s not going at all, and what that all means.
In the case of these three monographs, the researchers were asked not only to delve into the 2008 data, but also to place it in context with the large trove of data gathered by the SPPA since it was first administered in 1982.
These recaps take a while, so this just covers the first one…I’ll cover the other two next week.
The three monographs were:
- Arts Education in America: What the Declines Mean for Arts Participation, by Nick Rabkin and Eric Hedberg of the NORC Center at the University of Chicago.
- Age and Arts Participation: A Case Against Demographic Destiny, by Mark Stern of the University of Pennsylvania.
- Beyond Attendance: A Multi-Modal Understanding of Arts Participation, by Jennifer Novak-Leonard and Alan Brown of WolfBrown
Arts Education in America
Building off of an initial study commissioned by the NEA in 1992 that indicated that arts education was the most powerful predictor of arts attendance in adults, this study analyzed the data in the SPPA since 1982 to understand more fully exactly how central arts education is in the creation of future arts patrons.
Nick Rabkin eased us in with some basic graphs demonstrating facts we sort of already know – that those who repot having had classes in art are far more likely to report they’ve also attended arts events across the life of the SPPA, and then that general education is itself a correlated indicator of arts attendance (more education = more attendance).
Then things got interesting. Rabkin analyzed the number of art forms respondents indicated they had studied, both as a child and as an adult, and found that an increase not only in any arts education, but of a diverse arts education yielded higher average rates of arts attendance in respondents – and that the effect was even more evident with art forms studied as an adult. To pause here for a second, this seems to go against the current prevailing mutterings from some circles that the current adult generation may be simply lost to arts apathy, and that the focus should instead completely divert to children. Here’s the graph (taken from their presentation):
F1. Arts Attendance Rate Predictions Based on Amount of Arts Attendance

Taking, then, the fact that arts education is indeed quite important, Rabkin and Hedberg began an analysis of what has happened to arts education over the course of the SPPA, and indeed, over the last century.
Starting simply, they looked at the percentage of 18-year-olds in each SPPA since 1982 who said they had had arts education as children. The numbers starkly declined from a 1982 high of 64% to a low in 2008 of 49.5%. The pace of decline is increasing precipitously as well. This itself indicates something of an issue, but then Rabkin and Hedberg did something fascinating. They extrapolated the ages of each of the respondents on every SPPA since 1982, and where from there able to figure out the year at which each person turned 18. Using that as an anchor, they laid out the percentage of respondents who experienced arts education as children for every year between 1930 and 2008, with this result:
F2. Percentage of Childhood Arts Education, 1930-2008

What this graph shows is that in 1930, about 20% of children had any arts education. The number steadily rose until 1985, when it was at about 65%. It then began a consistent downward trend, passing through 50% in 2000. Per Rabkin, this downturn was precipitated by:
- Widespread opposition to taxes associated with arts education, beginning with Prop 13 (right here in California).
- The emergence of school reform as a high national priority. The report that spurred this reform effort was called “Nation at Risk,” and was published in 1983. It encouraged raising standards and rigorous testing, and included practically no discussion of arts education. Per Rabkin, arts education has been marginalized ever since.
A 15% decline is upsetting, but the problem is actually even more disasterous than on first look. The issue is that that decline is disproportionately affecting non-white populations, and not just a little. Since 1982, arts education for white has essentially stayed constant at about 58% of students. African-Americans and Hispanics, on the other hand, have seen a decline from around 50% of students in 1982 to half (!) that in 2008. The graph is incredibly disheartening:
F3. % of Respondents Reporting Arts Education As Children by Race
I’ve written at length about the terribly disproportionate impact of arts education cuts on non-white populations. Essentially, it is a situation of discrimination by default—schools in less affluent districts (districts where neither the local municipality nor the parents can afford to shoulder the financial burden of providing arts education to their children) suffer more than schools in more affluent districts, and less affluent districts are disproportionately non-white. As I said in an article on this subject last year:
In a country where, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, the 2006 median household income for a whlte family was 158% that of a black family and 135% that of an Hispanic family, the fact that ubiquity of arts education is directly tied to affluence means that it’s de facto tied to race.
Rabkin closed with some thoughts on the relationship between the decline in interest in the arts and the decline in arts education, and cautioned not to draw instant, direct connections between the two – at least not only in one direction. Declining arts education may contribute to declining interest in the arts, but it can also go the other way, becoming what Rabkin called “a bi-directional issue.”
Rabkin also cautioned us to understand that moaning about arts attendance and its ties to arts education isn’t going to get us very far with our legislators. In his term, he expected such arguments to be viewed as “trivial.” Rather, we need to advocate for arts education on its own terms, secure in the knowledge that instituting such reform will likely generate some increase in arts attendance in the years to come.
Labels: #SupplyDemand, advocacy, arts education, arts participation, attendance, audience development, diversity, engagement, envisioning alternatives, NEA
1431 Comments:
«Oldest ‹Older 1401 – 1431 of 1431-
At
October 23, 2024 at 5:10 AM ,
arelyaidan said...
-
-
At
October 27, 2024 at 12:57 AM ,
kal mokke said...
-
-
At
November 3, 2024 at 2:40 AM ,
کبیرپانل said...
-
-
At
November 4, 2024 at 4:57 AM ,
sanradavid said...
-
-
At
November 4, 2024 at 8:58 PM ,
mila said...
-
-
At
November 13, 2024 at 3:11 AM ,
Amm Hotel couture said...
-
-
At
November 14, 2024 at 6:25 AM ,
My Nightmate said...
-
-
At
December 4, 2024 at 3:19 AM ,
payexel solutions said...
-
-
At
December 17, 2024 at 4:19 AM ,
UAE Visa said...
-
-
At
December 18, 2024 at 12:49 AM ,
Azerbaijan visa said...
-
-
At
December 18, 2024 at 12:56 AM ,
Vokit Visa said...
-
-
At
December 18, 2024 at 3:51 AM ,
دکتر کیانا صادقی said...
-
-
At
December 18, 2024 at 5:07 AM ,
One Empire said...
-
-
At
December 20, 2024 at 3:24 AM ,
Lisa said...
-
-
At
December 25, 2024 at 9:00 AM ,
kinselygreyson said...
-
-
At
January 1, 2025 at 10:32 PM ,
hilsonsmith said...
-
-
At
January 2, 2025 at 8:24 PM ,
Andy Mardi said...
-
-
At
January 4, 2025 at 3:58 AM ,
Sonal said...
-
-
At
January 6, 2025 at 12:13 AM ,
House Of Fakir Chand said...
-
-
At
January 6, 2025 at 3:31 AM ,
The Second Project said...
-
-
At
January 6, 2025 at 3:57 AM ,
The Home Dekor said...
-
-
At
January 7, 2025 at 2:36 AM ,
Gupta Stone said...
-
-
At
January 7, 2025 at 3:12 AM ,
The Home Dekor said...
-
-
At
January 8, 2025 at 4:56 AM ,
sloaneparker said...
-
-
At
January 27, 2025 at 9:54 PM ,
The Home Dekor said...
-
-
At
January 30, 2025 at 12:51 AM ,
https://softwaretrainingsiddipet.in/ said...
-
-
At
February 3, 2025 at 8:37 AM ,
nicofinn said...
-
-
At
February 5, 2025 at 9:47 PM ,
john smith said...
-
-
At
February 8, 2025 at 12:57 AM ,
Utkrsh1815 said...
-
-
At
February 14, 2025 at 1:51 AM ,
Clonko said...
-
-
At
February 14, 2025 at 10:12 PM ,
True Care Counselling said...
-
«Oldest ‹Older 1401 – 1431 of 1431
I’ll dive into it and give it a try right away! lhi optum provider portal
تعمیرات مبل در شهران ، جهت دریافت قیمت تعمیرات و اطلاعات بیشتر به سایت
مبل رسولی
I pay a quick visit day-to-day a few web sites and information sites to read articles,
but this blog offers quality based articles.
کبیر پانل
ساندویچ پانل
قیمت ساندویچ پانل
It's disheartening to see the decline in arts education based on the latest data. The numbers speak for themselves, highlighting the urgent need for action to support and prioritize arts education in schools. Arts education is not just about creativity and self-expression; it's about critical thinking, problem-solving, and fostering well-rounded individuals. As a community, we must advocate for the arts and ensure that all students have access to a comprehensive arts education. Let's use these new numbers as a call to arms to fight for the future of arts education and the well-being of our students.
How Many Points is a Speeding Ticket in Virginia Fairfax
The post discusses RobustTechHouse's approach to simplifying life and the importance of small, intentional changes. It encourages mindful living and stress reduction. RobustTechHouse has been featured by RatingsG, highlighting its innovative tech solutions and digital transformation. The author is impressed by RobustTechHouse's work and eagerly anticipates future developments. sex crime lawyer Your trusted advocate in the legal maze. With a passion for justice and a track record of winning cases, I turn complex challenges into clear solutions. Let's navigate your legal journey together!
Choosing the proper chef work uniform is essential for your kitchen staff’s comfort, safety, and professionalism. Finding reliable kitchen clothing suppliers who offer high-quality restaurant uniforms is essential to outfit your team. Whether you want chef uniforms online or need a trusted chef uniform supplier, this guide will help you make the best choice for your business.
Its very interesting post, keep sharing about sex toys for men and more sexual wellness posts. thanks for sharing.
Mobile app development is the process of creating software applications designed to run on mobile devices, combining innovative design, coding, and functionality to deliver seamless user experiences and meet specific business or personal needs across platforms like iOS and Android.
loved your blog
dubai visa
Nice Blog
Azerbaijan visa for Honduras Passport holders
Informative Cotent
Duabi Visa for Belize Citizens
این ترکیب هوشمندانه، به خودرو امکان می دهد تا هم مصرف سوخت را کاهش دهد و هم آلایندگی کمتری تولید کند. در ادامه مقاله، به تعریف و بررسی ویژگی ها و مزایای خودروهای هیبریدی خواهیم پرداخت تا با این تکنولوژی پیشرفته بیشتر آشنا شویم. با وب سایت طلوع همراه باشید.
At One Empire, we make it easy for you to find the lingerie set online, designed to enhance your style, comfort, and confidence. Whether you’re looking for cute lingerie sets for a fun, flirty vibe or sophisticated designs for special occasions, our collection has it all. Discover the convenience of shopping for the perfect lingerie set online and indulge in luxury that’s both affordable and high-quality.
The decline in arts education is concerning, highlighting a growing focus on STEM subjects. Balancing creative and technical skills is vital for holistic development. Platforms like the assignment desk offer online management assignment help, empowering students to excel in diverse fields.
The recent statistics on declining arts education are quite alarming. It's disheartening to see the numbers reflecting a decrease in funding and support for arts programs in schools. As a society, we must prioritize the arts in education to nurture creativity, innovation, and critical thinking skills in our future generations. These new figures only strengthen the urgent need for action to reverse this trend and ensure that every student has access to a well-rounded education that includes the arts. Let's use these numbers as a wake-up call to advocate for the importance of arts education and work towards creating a more vibrant and culturally rich society for all.
Reckless Driving Lawyer Harrisonburg VA
Completing assignments in human resources can be complex, especially when delving into topics like recruitment strategies and employee relations. With my experience in teaching HR concepts, I always recommend students maintain clarity in their work. If you find it challenging to balance the content and analysis, Assignment Help Liverpool can be incredibly beneficial. An online assignment helper can guide you through structuring your ideas, offering detailed insights into HR theories, and ensuring your work is aligned with academic expectations. Always focus on the relevance of examples to improve the depth of your analysis
thats was amazing article you wrote PPaket Wisata Singapore
Website design is evolving rapidly with trends like AI personalization, voice navigation, and interactive 3D elements taking center stage. Global Key Info Solutions stays ahead of these trends and focuses on mobile-first designs, fast load times, and user-friendly layouts to ensure your website is trendy and effective. Let us help you create a future-ready website that perfectly aligns with your business goals!
Absolutely loved this article! Your writing is clear, concise, and really engaging.
Custom Made Indian Wedding Lehenga
Name badge custom is an excellent way to build trust and improve communication within your business. They help clients and visitors quickly identify the right person, enhancing interaction and promoting a professional atmosphere. With custom name badge, you can ensure your team’s identity is aligned with your company’s vision, making your employees proud to represent your brand.
At The Home Dekor, we offer a variety of console table designed to add style and functionality to your home. Whether you want to enhance your hallway, living room, or entryway, our console table online collection provides the perfect options to suit your needs.
At Gupta Stone, we are proud to be a leading Lime Stone Supplier, providing high-quality limestone products for a variety of applications. Whether you’re working on construction, landscaping, or architectural projects, our limestone is sourced from the best quarries, ensuring durability, aesthetic appeal, and strength for all your needs.
Looking for the perfect crockery unit online? At The Home Dekor, we offer a wide range of elegant and functional crockery cabinets online that are designed to enhance your dining room or kitchen. Our collection of crockery units online is crafted with attention to detail, offering ample space to store and display your beautiful crockery collection while adding a touch of sophistication to your home. Whether you're looking for a modern design or something more traditional, our crockery cabinet online caters to every taste and style.
virginia pedestrian accident attorney
"Such an important conversation! The decline of arts education is a serious issue that affects not only students' creativity but also their ability to think critically, solve problems, and express themselves. The arts are essential for developing well-rounded individuals who can contribute to society in unique and meaningful ways. We need to prioritize arts education to ensure that future generations have the tools they need to innovate, connect, and thrive in an ever-changing world. Let’s continue to advocate for the value of the arts in schools!"
Looking for the perfect blend of style and functionality in a service tray? At The Home Dekor, we offer a variety of service trays at the best service tray price. Whether you’re hosting a dinner party or need a stylish way to organize your essentials, our trays combine beauty and practicality at affordable prices.
Your review is informative and gives a clear picture of your experience. Adding a comparison with similar drinks might make it even more insightful.
Explore more digital solutions at T Digital Agency https://tdigitalagency.com/
Arts education is vital for creativity and critical thinking, yet it's declining at an alarming rate. The new statistics highlight the urgent need for renewed investment in the arts. Without action, students lose essential skills and cultural enrichment. This discussion is crucial—let’s advocate for stronger arts programs in schools!
Conducir Sin Prueba Licencia Nueva Jersey
Struggling with your law dissertation help? Writing a well-structured and plagiarism-free dissertation requires thorough research and strong writing skills. Using a grammar checker ensures error-free content, improving readability and professionalism. However, expert guidance can make a significant difference. Assignment Desk offers professional law dissertation help, assisting with topic selection, research, and proofreading. Our experts ensure your work is well-researched, properly formatted, and grammatically flawless. Don’t let complex legal concepts hold you back—get expert support and submit a high-quality dissertation with confidence. Contact us today for reliable law dissertation help and make your academic journey smoother!
Want to study in Canada? Fanshawe College Canada offers flexible programs, scholarship options, and practical learning experiences. Start your application with Gradding today!
Thank you for providing this content. I Appreciate the time and effort that you have put into creating it.
High-end comfort and strength within your yoga practice are available with the Clonko Yoga Mat. The premium mat features a suitable design for every skill level with stellar grip along with premium cushioning through environmentally friendly materials to provide a flawless exercise experience.
Visit Us -
Online Buy Yoga Mat
6MM TPE Yoga Mat
Best Quality TPE Yoga Mat
Best Price Premium Yoga Mat
Bipolar Disorder is a mental health disorder distinguished by severe mood swings that contain emotional thrills (mania or hypomania) and lows (depression). During manic stages, people may encounter improved energy, impulsivity, and high tempers, while emotions of unhappiness, distress, and exhaustion mark depressive stages. These mood changes can significantly affect everyday functioning and connections. The reason is not fully comprehended but is believed to involve hereditary, environmental, and neurochemical aspects. Therapy typically affects prescription (such as mood stabilizers or antidepressants) and counselling to assist in managing Bipolar Disorder Symptoms and enhance the quality of life.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home